Tuesday, August 26, 2014

  Maslow’s:

Physiological Need - food, air, water, shelter.
Safety Need - security of body, health, property.
Belonging or love Need - friendship, family, communicate. 
Esteem Need - confidence, self-esteem, achievement, respect.
Self-Actualization Need - creativity, problems solving, acceptance.

 Rosenberg’s:

Physical Nurturing - food, breathing, water, sleep.
Interdependence - dependence
Love intergrity - honesty Autonomy - independence
Celebration and mourning - helping in feeling
Spiritual Communication - religion.

Bases on two hierachy above, I thing they are all have the same points . First, they are both mention about human need in life which are food, breathing, water, sleep, etc. After that, Maslow and Rosenberg are both mentioned about the safety and dependence of human like human rights and protection. Then is the feeling of being loved, connected and be able to communicated with others, this lead to the human need of personal feeling, which also mentioned in both hierachy.

 

 But not all of the hierachies are completely the same. There’re also some differrent points bwtween them. In the Manslow's hierachy, he just only show us about human basical need, those hierachy are simply the basic step of human need and less focusing than the Rosenberg's hierachy, which is more significantly and critical. In fact, point of view in Manslow's hierachy that human not as greedy as in Rosenberg's. For me, I think the Rosenberg’s one is better, it shows us fully about what human actually needs and even more significantly than Maslow.